There is a lot of banking research on the blog, but we decided to start from scratch with a fresh start and a tweaked set of criteria, which I have outlined below.
| Stage | Process |
| Initial List | List of 229 banks in U.S with market cap greater than $100 mn |
| Step 1 | Divided the banks into the following three sets to analyze each set individually |
| Set A | Banks with Texas ratio of more than 50% |
| Set B | Banks with Texas ratio of less than 50% but more than 30% |
| Set C | Banks with Texas ratio of less than 30% |
| Step 2 | Sub-divided each set further into three categories |
| 1) Shortable set - Banks with share price of more than $10 and free float of more than 20 million shares | |
| 2) Banks with share price of more than $10 but free float of less than 20 million shares | |
| 3) Banks with share price of less than $10 | |
| INITIAL SCREENING - The selection criteria was to to find banks which continue to have high accumulated NPLs in the balance sheet and continue to record relatively high charge-off rates (loan losses), resulting in negative earnings and erosion of equity. | |
| Step 3 | In Set A and Set B , banks were selected in the first two sub-categories. In Set C, banks were selected only in the first category. |
| Major parameters used | |
| a) Charge-off rates in the last quarter is higher than 2.5% of total loans | |
| b) Loan loss coverage, i.e, Charge-offs/ (Pretax income + Provisions for loan losses) in the last quarter was less than 1.5x | |
| c) Return on equity in the last quarter and on TTM basis is negative or extremely low | |
| d) Coverage ratio (Allowance for loan losses to Non-performing assets) is less than 40% | |
| e) Price-to tangible book value is more than 1.5x | |
| Step 4 | Banks selected in Set A, Set B and Set C in each sub-categories were consolidated to produce two separate lists |
| List 1 | Selected banks in step 3 with share price of more than $10 and free float of more than 20 million shares |
| List 2 | Selected banks in step 3 with share price is more than $10 but float less than than 20 mn shares |
| FINAL SHORTLISTING - The primary shortlisting criteria was to to find overvalued banks in terms of high 2011e P/E and high 2011 Price-to-tangible book value. Estimates for 2011e EPS and 2011e Tangible book value per share are based on consensus estimates sourced from Bloomberg | |
| Step 5 | Banks with relatively high 2011e P/E ratio while having weak fundamental were selected. A total of 13 banks have been finally shortlisted from the two lists |
| Final shortlisted banks | Banks with high 2011e P/E as well as high 2011 Price-to-tangible book value are highlighted in green |
| Banks with high 2011e P/E but low 2011 Price-to-tangible book value are highlighted in blue | |
We have 4 banks that have returned to us from the original Doo Doo 32 list from two years ago (yes, many of those banks went bust, but there are still a few stalwart living dead traipsing around), while everyone else is brand spanking new to the watch list. All paying subscribers may access the live spreadsheet here.
For those of you who don't subscribe, here is a freebie. It's nowhere on top of the list, but it does provide food for thought:
| Ticker | Short name | Price | P/Tangible BVPS (2011e) | ROE (based on 2010e earnings) | ROE (based on 2011e earnings) | Market cap | Float (mn) | Price as % of 52 week high | Price as % of 52 week low | 52 week high | 52 week low | P/B | P/Tangible BVPS | Tier 1 ratio | Tangible Equity/ Tangible assets | Loan-to Deposit ratio | Texas ratio | Coverage ratio | Charge-off rate | Provisions to charge-offs | Loan loss coverage |
| Final shortlisted | |||||||||||||||||||||
| PBIB US Equity | PORTER BANCORP I | 13.6 | 1.00 | 6.0% | 7.8% | 120 | 3.0 | 78.6% | 128.1% | 17.2 | 10.6 | 0.9 | 1.04 | 12.2 | 6.6% | 91.6% | 81.0% | 23.2% | 0.8% | 105.3% | 2.7 |

Tweet me!
