PDF Print E-mail

What does Brittany Spears, Snow White and MBIA have in Common?

User Rating: / 0
PoorBest 
Written by Reggie Middleton   
Tuesday, 11 December 2007

This is part one of a two part response to comments and questions on the recent events concerning the Ambac and MBIA. The second part will be a forensic marking to market of Ambac's portfolio based upon the recent E*Trade sale. Required reading for this article includes:
  1. A Super Scary Halloween Tale of 104 Basis Points Pt I & II, by Reggie Middleton.
  2. Ambac is Effectively Insolvent & Will See More than $8 Billion of Losses with Just a $2.26 Billion Market Cap
  3. Follow up to the Ambac Analysis
  4. Monolines swoon, CDOs go boom & I really wonder why the ratings agencies are given any credibility
  5. Bill Ackman of Pershing Square - How to save the Monolines

Note: this came directly from one of my analysts, who seems to have been infected by my smart ass writing style :-)

MBIA � The company mentioned that "fair value" of their portfolio dropped by $850 million in the one month between September 30 and October 30, 2007. That speaks volumes. As far as equity infusion is concerned, MBIA is merely replacing the capital they have already lost. This may sound simplistic, but this is how it is. The caveat is, they are replacing it by diluting their current shareholders. Thus, those who did not do the math have bid the share price up, instead of down. Given the significant amount of exposure that the company has (MBIA has about $84 billion in residential ABS and CDO exposure), $1 billion of capital infusion at this point may not be sufficient; though it may keep off the immediate rating downgrade concern. The company has also mentioned that they�re setting aside $800 million to cover estimated losses on residential mortgage-backed securities in the fourth quarter. This will further impact its bottom line.

Regarding Warburg�s investment, although there is not much data available at this point to comment on the additional $500 million commitment based on the current share price or the approximate market price in the first quarter, I read an analyst quoting that based on an option-pricing model, the value of Warburg's warrants range from $3.14 to $6.55 a share which means that Warburg effectively paid less than $28 a share for the stock based on a conservative valuation of the warrants, or as low as $24.45 based on more aggressive estimates (http://online.wsj.com/article/SB119730169419019425.html?mod=yahoo_hs&ru=yahoo). Yet, again, the mathematically challenged bid the price up and above what Warburg was willing to pay.

When it comes to rating agencies �review�, I liked what Jonathan Weil said a couple of days back: If MBIA Is AAA, Britney Spears is Snow White J (http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=newsarchive&sid=aFwZKa2jzPfQ). Last week, credit- default swaps tied to MBIA Insurance Corp.'s bonds were 193 basis points, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. In other words, it cost about $193,000 to buy a contract protecting $10 million of bonds from default for five years. That implies about a 15% probability of default - for a company rated AAA. Keep in mind that the US treasuries are a AAA benchmark. Compare and contrast!

However, if MBIA (and other bond insurers such as Ambac, Radian, etc.) are able to raise capital to keep up with the losses, and, as the company talked about reviewing its capital management policies, writing more business and resorting to reinsurance, it is likely that the rating agencies may not downgrade the AAA rating. We still don't think the company will fare well with the potential losses coming down the pike, regardless of the rating agencies say.

2) Ambac � As highlighted in the valuation, we were conservative regarding the defaults in the company�s consumer finance portfolio since our emphasis was more on the Subprime RMBS and the Structured Finance portfolios. The potential losses in Ambac�s auto receivables portfolio, after subordination, ranges from $675 million to $2.5 billion, in different scenarios. In the base case, we estimate default rates in Ambac�s Auto Receivables portfolio as 11% which indicates total losses of $1.3 billion. However, like mentioned in the comment below, potential losses could be significantly more than our estimates. A spreadsheet with a full evaluation of this auto portfolio, losses and loss projections are available for premium subscribers.



Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! JoomlaVote! Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! Yahoo! Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
Trackback(0)
Comments (0)Add Comment

Write comment

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy

Last Updated ( Thursday, 08 January 2009 )
 
< Prev   Next >

Reggie's RSS
feed image

Reggie Middleton has 3,000 subscribers, worldwide!

Click on the slide!

The Hartford Subscribes to Reggie's Research

The Hartford Subscribes to Reggie's Research

More...
Click on the slide!

My Investment Style

My Investment Style!

More...
Click on the slide!

BNP Paribas subscribes to Reggie Middleton

BNP Paribas subscribes to Reggie Middleton

More...
Click on the slide!

Desjardins subscribes to Reggie Middleton

Desjardins subscribes to Reggie Middleton

More...
Click on the slide!

JP Morgan Subscribes to Reggie Middleton

JP Morgan Subscribes to Reggie Middleton

More...
Click on the slide!

Bank of America Subscribes to Reggie Middleton

Bank of America Subscribes to Reggie Middleton

More...
Click on the slide!

BoomBustBloggin' on the Motherland on the Hudson

BoomBustBloggin' on the Motherland on the Hudson

More...
Click on the slide!

The guys who came on the trip had a good time

Life is Good!

I'm hopeful that all who came along for the networking and fun event had a good time. My goal was…

More...
Click on the slide!

Protestant Episcopal Cathedral Foundation

The Protestant Episcopal Cathedral Foundation subscribes to Reggie Middletonhh

More...
Click on the slide!

This is BoomBustBloggin'

The water through the Palisades felt warmer than the air - 77 degrees

Whoa!!! This water feels good!!!

More...
Click on the slide!

Reggie vs the Hedge Funds

Reggie vs the Hegde Funds

More...
Click on the slide!

BoomBustBloggin' @ 79th St Boat Basin, NYC

Bloggin at the Boat Basin, via the Motherland.

More...
Click on the slide!

The NY Daily News Subscribes to Reggie Middleton

The NY Daily News Subscribes to Reggie Middleton

More...
Click on the slide!

Arriving @79th Street Boat Basin, via the Hudson River, on the MotherLand

Arriving @79th Street Boat Basin, via the Hudson River, on the MotherLand

More...
Click on the slide!

Deloitte Subscribes to Reggie Middleton

Deloitte Subscribes to Reggie Middleton

More...
Click on the slide!

BoomBustBlog Boat Trip!

On the Bow of the MotherLand - the BoomBustBlog Boat Trip

This is the BoomBustBlogger crew on the Bow of the MotherLand on the way up the Hudson River.

Click on the slide!

Fore Research subscribes to Reggie Middleton

Fore Research subscribes to Reggie Middleton

More...
Click on the slide!

The IMF subscribes to Reggie Middleton

The IMF listens to subscribes to Reggie

More...
Click on the slide!

Deutsche Bank Subscribes to Reggie Middleton

Deutsche Bank Subscribes to Reggie Middleton

More...
Click on the slide!

BoomBustBloggin' @BuddhaKahn

Another BoomBustBlog event. This one at BuddhaKahn, NYC.

More...
Click on the slide!

Morgan Stanley subscribes to Reggie Middleton

Morgan Stanley subscribes to Reggie Middleton

More...
Frontpage Slideshow (version 2.0.0) - Copyright © 2006-2008 by JoomlaWorks

Visit Reggie @:

3002 registered
0 today
5 yesterday
27 this week
37 this month
Visitors: 4892345
Reggie has 85 guests and 21 members online and is proud to announce 3002 confirmed members registered to access his opinion and analysis since Sept. 2007. We welcome the following new members:
• Boosun 0
• Pulkit 0
• Kenshin.kudo 0
• VoidStar 0
• Kevpal 0

Latest Comments

Time Warner and the ...
Reggie, This could signal the begining of the "Gr...
Insulet Corporation ...
Insulet Raised To Buy From Hold By Canaccord >PODD...
The Forensic Analysi...
http://seekingalpha.com/article/113694-the-ipo-dro...
Super Tankers, Super...
Frontline Slides, Despite Supertanker Demand, as F...
Amid the rally, I lo...
By Marshall Eckblad Of DOW JONES NEWSWIRES NEW YO...
Amid the rally, I lo...
KeyCorp, parent of Key Bank, got $2.5 billion from...
Amid the rally, I lo...
Sandeler O'Neill Analyst Forecasts 4Q Loss For JPM...

MyWebSite

I strongly recommend new users browse through my recent archives. There is a wealth of information here. Older archives are available through the "All Articles" link in the main menu.

Discussions

Re:Bailout
Reggie Middleton 13-10-08 17:30
Re:Bailout
laguy888 28-09-08 19:35
Bailout
Giganto 24-09-08 19:37